The Value of Critique Partners and Beta Readers

“Friend’s don’t let friends write crap.”

If you are a new author and are not a part of a critique group..find one immediately!!!!!

But don’t just join any group. Your critique group needs to consist of several key ingredients to make it work:

  • Everyone must write in the same genre.  Okay, this statement is more my personal opinion than fact, but it has also worked best for me. As we all know, each genre has sub categories, so as long as you find a group that focuses on the main part of the genre, you’re good.
  • Your personalities must be able to mesh together. If you aren’t comfortable with your partners, or can’t joke around with them when you’re not talking about writing and connect on another level…they may not be the group for you.
  • Develop a thick skin! The focus of a critique group is to have someone review your writing and offer honest feedback about your storyline, writing techniques and technical errors. No one is out to dog you or bring you down. Everyone’s goal is to lift up and make your writing better. You have to be willing to not only accept this, but to offer it as well.
  • Make time to assist your critique group members with their work as much as possible. One of the major rules of being a part of a group is to review work of others just like you want them to review yours. You can’t be a member and not participate. All writers have lives – be it at home as a homemaker, or a nine-to-five – our main focus is to complete our MS. As a group member, we all make time to critique other member’s work. Does this mean you have to meet a critique minimum, like one a day? Lord, I hope not, but different groups have different requirements. Make sure you review them and see if it will fit into your schedule. 
  • HAVE FUN!!!!! Writing should be a learning experience, a way to release your creativity and let ideas flow. If writing suddenly becomes a chore and is no longer fun… step away, take a break and see if you still have the urge to write. If not, then maybe being a reader and not an author is for you.

So, bet you’re wondering what brought this blog on, huh?

I’m working on the second round of edits for my first book, A Heart Not Easily Broken. The first round involved me having a beta reader- my cousin- take time out of her busy schedule to read my rough, typed up, completely unedited version of my story and give me honest feedback. That went really well. With no major issues or comment from her end, I proceeded to start my own round of edits.  During this process, I submitted my versions of the edited chapters to my critique partners for their feedback. Since this was being done chapter by chapter, I received feedback as I edited chapters further into the story. I reviewed their notes, answered questions and filed what they said away to come back to at another date. If they pointed out an issue with a character or plot point, I made note and picked up the correction in the later chapters I worked on. Last week I completed my first round of edits. Twenty-one chapters and an epilogue. Now I’m on to the second round.

Round two consists of pulling together all the critiques from each chapter and lining them up side-by-side on my computer screen, reading their comments, and deciding what and if it’s something I agree with and typing up a new page. Of course all technical errors are corrected, and sometimes the comments make me laugh, such as, “body parts doing something on their own is impossible”, or my personal favorite, “breast has an ‘s’ because there’re two of them!” LOL! Once that is completed, I review, check for repeated phrase/words and whittle down as many passive words as I can so my editor can do a happy dance that her work won’t be too difficult, and voila! I’m off to the next chapter!

The technique used to write this book is different from what I’ve done in the past. I’ve made it my goal to blog about every step I take so others who are like me, a new author who is unpublished but determined to make it, can see what I’ve learned along the way. Has everything been easy?…Uh, NO! But I’ve learned a lot. It has officially been two years of writing for me and man, oh man, have I come a long way! I hope you will refer to my past post and find something that can help or encourage you as you make your own journey.

Besides having my desire to see this project through to publication, I owe a lot to my critique partners, The Critter Yard, who are some of the most talented and hardworking women I know. All are published authors, some you may have heard of. They are, Chicki Brown, Ednah Walters, Erin Kern, and Zee Monodee, and up and coming author, Jessica J. Clarke. All of these wonderful ladies have seen success in their writing dreams, and have lovingly accepted me with open arms as a novice writer. I will admit, I was nervous when I first submitted my work – one year ago. I was so confident in my story and my knowledge as a new writer I knew I was on my way. My goal of having my work published by the end of the year was destined to happen… Ladies, I know you’re laughing your butts off right now. So am I, but honestly, that’s what I thought!

And then, I started receiving their critiques…

And I realized, I showed promise, but wasn’t there just yet.

Questions like, “What genre is this exactly?” made me pause. “Romance,” I said, then was nicely advised that there are many sub-genre’s within the genre. Yep, I still had a lot to learn. But thankfully, the women weren’t harsh in their comments. They offered me tips and advice, even when they had to repeat themselves because I didn’t get it the first time. When I felt like I had to step away and take a break from writing, they understood. And when I finally felt strong enough to submit my newest project for their honest feedback, they were just as excited as I am to see the obvious growth in my writing.


And you can never forget Beta Readers!

You know, the ones you scope out and wonder if they will take the time and read your work and give not technical feedback like critique partners, but actual story line feedback?

“Does this make sense? Does my storyline interest you? Would you consider buying this book if you read the cover?”

Family and close friends don’t always make the best beta readers unless you know without a doubt they will give honest feedback. Mine have, thank God. My number one beta reader is the ONLY reason why I’ve continued to go forth with this story! In the past, she’s read my work and had no problem telling me she does not like the story line and why. Each time, her feedback made sense. I took what she – and believe it or not, my husband’s too – had to say and worked diligently to make the characters three-dimensional and realistic as possible.  I slaved away for months, refusing to share  details with her unless I needed to use her as a sounding board for my ideas. When I finished, I asked her to read it. After several hours, she promptly stomped her way downstairs and demanded I finish typing up the rest of the story – it was all written by hand – so she could finish reading it ASAP! When she finished, I drilled her for fifteen-minutes, just waiting on her to say something needed to change or at least have a question about why so-and-so did this. She had none and gave me the green light to move on.

Why was that so important? Because she does not, and I mean, DOES NOT read romance! Having her give me a thumbs-up let me know that I should be able to capture anyone’s attention with this story, romance reader or not.  So, if you are blessed to have someone like her in your life, take advantage of that resource!


The following are links that have been suggested to me for those who are unable to locate a critique group in your area or are in need of honest feedback. I haven’t checked them out yet, but feel free to do so:

Time to jump back in to my editing! Until later, Write On!


Connect with me on the following sites: 





    12 thoughts on “The Value of Critique Partners and Beta Readers

    1. So very true!! I wholeheartedly agree with all you said. I owe everything to my critique partner, and also to my beta readers. Without them I feel I'd be in a dinghy, in the middle of the ocean, without a paddle.

    2. Great post, MJ! I'm so glad you didn't hold any of my comments against me. 🙂 When we met, I could tell that you were determined to get your writing published, and I'm blessed to be able to work with you!The best is yet to come.

    3. @Angela….I think I was sitting somewhere in the middle of the Atlantic trying to paddle with a tea spoon before the ladies found me!@Chicki…Thanks so much! I'll never hold the comments against anyone. In fact they often make me laugh and say, "Yeah, that does sound impossible. Wonder why it sounded right the first time?????" LOL!

    4. Arghh – typed a post and Blogger ate it!Loved the post, girl, and lol, thank YOU too for being there for all of us and helping along the way. The road to calling oneself an author doesn't stop at getting published – in fact, it is just the start. And in those times, we need CPs and mostly friends who 'get' us and whom we can trust more than anything.XOXO

    5. What a great description of how much it takes to get a story polished for publication and the partnerships that make it possible. I never used to think that critique partners had to be writing in the same genre, but I have found that the most insightful comments come from those who are. Good luck with your book! I look foward to seeing it on Amazon 🙂

    6. It's not just new writers who need critique partners. I've had five novels published (and another one due out next Feb), but I'm still indebted to my two critique partners and their comments and suggestions. I couldn't survive without them!

    7. @Ruth and @Paula….thanks for you comments! I used to be part of a writer's group when I first started writing, unfortunately most members were poets and one is a play rite. All are wonderful people, but now one could give me the feedback I needed for the Romance genre, but the did teach me the basic rules of writing format and story telling structure. For that I am extremely grateful. The group I'm in now is strictly Romance genre writers, but we all tackle different aspects, one does Chick Lit, Paranormal, Sensual/Action, and Romance/Christian Fiction. I write Multicultural/Woman's Fiction. They've been able to point out rules of the genre that I didn't know. From there I've pulled what I feel works best for me and found my writing voice/style. Very helpful!

    8. M J Thank you for this blog. I am a fan of your website and your books. You are inspiring and refreshing. I look up and admire you so much.
      I just went through the first bad review drama yesterday and I almost threw in towel. But…after my petty party and the support of the Fiction Writers Group, I discovered I am a ball and I bounce and the points that you made concerning how important and crucial critique partners are is so very true. We need to swallow our pride and realize that we alone are far from perfect. Good, solid, honest advice and opinions from someone you trust can make all the difference in the world. Toughen up sister writers, we are in this together. Thank you again,
      Christine Hilton

      • Hey, Christine, hang in there! Yep, good writers never write alone! I have had some reviews that left me cringing, but after having the support of crit partners and my editors, I can proudly say the one thing no one could say is that the book was full of errors or poorly written. 🙂 In the end a review is all about personal opinion and you can’t please everyone. The best you can do is tell the best story you can, and trust your crit partners when they point out things for you to work on. Good luck with your continued writing endeavors!!

    Leave a Reply

    Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

    You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

    Google photo

    You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

    Connecting to %s